Mortgage Recast Calculator

Should You Recast Your Mortgage or Invest the Lump Sum?

Say $100,000 lands in your lap: a bonus, an inheritance, the proceeds after selling the old house. Two moves compete for it. Recast the mortgage and watch the monthly payment drop, or put the money in the market and chase a bigger return. I have a clear opinion on this one, but first the numbers, because the answer really does hinge on your rate.

What $100,000 Does as a Recast

A recast re-amortizes your remaining balance over the remaining term at your original rate. On a mortgage with a roughly $3,096 principal-and-interest payment, a $100,000 lump sum followed by a recast drops the payment to about $2,415. That is $682 back in your pocket every month, or $8,179 a year, for a processing fee of $150 to $400 and a phone call.

Here is the part people miss: the recast is a guaranteed return equal to your mortgage rate. Every dollar of principal you pay down is a dollar you stop paying 6.5% (or whatever your rate is) on. That is a risk-free 6.5% after tax, year after year. You do not get that guarantee anywhere else.

The comparison, honestly. Over long stretches, the stock market has returned roughly 9 to 10% a year nominal, which is ahead of a 6.5% mortgage. But that return is lumpy, taxable, and arrives whenever it arrives. The recast return is 6.5% and it is certain. If your rate is 3%, the gap in favor of investing is wide. If your rate is 7%, the recast looks very good. I would frame it this way: the higher your rate, the more the recast behaves like a great bond you cannot buy anywhere else.

Should You Recast or Invest? My Decision Rule

Recast the lump sum if any of these are true: your mortgage rate is 6% or higher, the lower monthly payment would let you quit something you hate (a second job, a side gig, overtime you do not want), or you are the kind of person who would panic-sell the investment the first time it drops 20%. The recast buys you breathing room you can feel every month.

Invest it instead if your rate is under 5%, your emergency fund is already full, and you will not touch the money for at least a decade. There is a middle path people forget: make the lump sum as extra principal without recasting. The payment stays the same, the interest savings are identical, and you pay the loan off years earlier. Then if life changes, you can still recast later for the lower payment. Most servicers let you recast at any point while the loan is current.

The liquidity catch. Money in your house is not money you can reach. A $100,000 recast cannot be undone with a phone call. If your emergency fund is thin, keep the cash liquid first. This is the one thing that makes me hesitate about recasting even when the rate math favors it: a guaranteed 6.5% means nothing if you need $20,000 next month and it is sitting in your drywall.

What a Recast Does Not Do

Two facts to lock in before you decide. First, a recast does not change your interest rate or your loan term. If rates have fallen well below yours, a refinance beats a recast; I compared the two head to head in Recast vs Refinance: Which Saves More. Second, the recast is nearly always a conventional-loan move. FHA, VA, and USDA loans generally cannot be recast, so on those loans the choice is between extra principal payments and investing, full stop.

Run your own numbers before you call your servicer: our mortgage recast calculator shows the new payment, the interest saved, and the invest-vs-recast comparison side by side. And if you want the mechanics of what happens to the payment itself, recast vs extra principal payments walks through it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should you recast your mortgage or invest the lump sum?

It depends on your rate. A recast at 6.5% is a guaranteed 6.5% after-tax return plus lower monthly payments. Investing historically beats that but with risk and volatility. Recast if you need payment relief or carry a high rate; invest if your rate is low and your emergency fund is full.

What is the return on a mortgage recast?

The return equals your mortgage rate, guaranteed and after tax. Paying down a 6.5% loan earns you 6.5% a year on that money because you stop paying 6.5% interest on it.

Can I recast later if an emergency hits?

Yes. Most servicers let you recast at any time while the loan is current, usually for a fee of $150 to $400. Money put into the house is illiquid, though: you cannot pull it back out quickly.

Does a recast save more interest than just making an extra principal payment?

The interest saved is the same for the same principal reduction. The difference is the payment: a recast lowers your required monthly payment, while an extra principal payment alone leaves the payment unchanged and shortens the payoff instead.

Want more of these? I write one practical guide a week on money, careers, and tools that pay for themselves. Subscribe free here.

Run the Recast vs Invest Numbers

Enter your balance, rate, and lump sum to compare the new payment, the interest saved, and what investing the same money could do.

Compare Recast vs Invest